University of Limerick Institutional Repository

When is a foetus not an unborn? Fatal foetal abnormalities and article 40.3.3°

DSpace Repository

Show simple item record Schweppe, Jennifer Spain, Eimear 2015-08-05T15:41:03Z 2015-08-05T15:41:03Z 2013
dc.description peer-reviewed en_US
dc.description.abstract The inability of women carrying foetuses suffering from fatal abnormalities to access a termination in this jurisdiction has been discussed widely in the media and the political sphere in recent times. Diverging views have emerged on whether Article 40.3.3 could accommodate terminations in these circumstances with the government taking the view that the termination of a pregnancy of this nature is not permissible under the Irish Constitution. This article proposes to unpick this presumption, focusing on three interpretations of Article 40.3.3which would permit terminations in these circumstances. The first argument is that the definition of the unborn does not include a foetus which does not have the capacity to survive outside the womb where such incapacity is not due exclusively to extreme immaturity. Secondly, it is argued that the life in question (that is, unviable life) can not be considered equal to the right to life of the mother. Finally it is argued that it is not practicable for the State to defend and vindicate this life. Essentially it is a question of whether there is a shift in the manner in which the two rights are balanced in these circumstances. Ultimately, it is argued that the termination of foetuses suffering from fatal abnormalities, such that they are incompatible with life outside the womb, is constitutionally permissible, and that a referendum to allow such terminations is not necessary. It is inevitable that a case involving circumstances such as these will appear before the Irish courts: we argue that the Government should pre-empt such a case, and legislate to allow for terminations where the foetus is suffering from a fatal abnormality. en_US
dc.language.iso eng en_US
dc.publisher University College Cork en_US
dc.relation.ispartofseries Irish Journal of Legal Studies;3 (3), article 6
dc.subject fatal foetal abnormalities en_US
dc.subject termination en_US
dc.subject unborn en_US
dc.title When is a foetus not an unborn? Fatal foetal abnormalities and article 40.3.3° en_US
dc.type info:eu-repo/semantics/article en_US
dc.type.supercollection all_ul_research en_US
dc.type.supercollection ul_published_reviewed en_US
dc.rights.accessrights info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess en_US
dc.internal.rssid 1415884

Files in this item

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record

Search ULIR


My Account