A framework for analysing the evolution of the IS field - can IS become a stable discipline?

Abstract

why this is the case, and puts forward a framework which has been developed to analyse the emergence of the IS field, its relationship with associated disciplines, and the problems it currently faces. These problems are of a fundamental nature and include the field's identity crisis and epistemological problems; the failure to erect barriers to entry; the reference discipline problem; and the trend towards increased divergence rather than harmony and convergence in the field. Urgent research is needed to lay the foundation of a model for progress in the IS field which will support the evolution of the field towards control and harmony. This need is now stronger than ever at a time when the status of IS comes under attack in academic circles and the field seems to be under pressure to establish a stronger identity and solve fundamental methodological problems.